The Old Methodist Cemetery: Preserving Toms River’s Methodist History

The Old Methodist Cemetery: Preserving Toms River’s Methodist History

Cemeteries in New Jersey face similar challenges of not having sufficient funding for maintenance, subject to varying oversight and little protection if any under state law. Preservation New Jersey recognized these issues and made cemeteries statewide one of the 10 Most Endangered Historic Places of 2022. Since then, there has been incremental progress. What I want to share today is a success story that is happening now to address one piece of the statewide problem. The preservation of the Old Methodist Cemetery on the corner of Washington Street and Hooper Avenue in Downtown Toms River.

This cemetery deeded to the Methodists of what would become the First United Methodist Church of Toms River then (Methodist Episcopal Church) holds a special place in the early history of Toms River and Methodist life in the village. The church’s first meeting house was erected on the site and many trustees, Revolutionary War and Civil War veterans are interred here. It also witnessed the evolution of the village of just over 2,000 people in 1828 to an anchor to the new County Courthouse in 1850 across the corner and now a town that is the 8th most populous in the state. Meanwhile, by 1975 the church had moved to a new location a few miles away.

Because of all these factors, the cemetery was subject to encroachment over time. Originally deeded at 1 acre, it is now ¾ of an acre surrounded by surface parking lots for the County Court and Probation. Sporadic efforts to clean the grounds and repair markers over the years by scout troops and trustees of the County Corrections left fixes that did not quite stand the test of time. Since then, monuments fell, cracked, sunk into the ground, and more leaves, sticks, acorns and other debris built up on the ground.

I found the cemetery in 2019 when I was asked to be the church historian. Not knowing what I was getting myself into, I enthusiastically started fall and spring cleanups and mowing the lawn while learning about cemetery preservation in books and from the National Parks Service. In 2022 the cemetery was given a very intensive survey as a part of a Master’s Degree program at Monmouth University. It was the first survey done since the New Jersey Genealogical Society in 1933, but instead of just the name and dates it included much more detailed information such as the dimensions of the stone, epitaph and listed family relations and more. After the survey was completed a conditions assessment was undertaken to understand the work needed and how much it would cost. That total came to $25,000, of which half was raised with contributions from the Trustees of the Church, members, outside individuals and groups like the Capt. Joshua Huddy DAR. This allowed Phase 1 of work to commence in early October by Roth Cemetery Services. They leveled and fixed fractured stones, starting with ones that needed the most work.

With Phase 1 now complete, there is still work to be done for Phase 2. To date $11,500 is still needed to finish the preservation work in time for the 200th Anniversary of the cemetery being deeded to the Methodists in 2028. Publicity, presentations, appeals play a huge part in making it a success. So, I ask you readers to help chip in directly and make a preservation success story happen. Play a part in reversing a trend of forgotten and neglected cemeteries right here in New Jersey.

If you would like to contribute any amount you can do so online at fumctr.com or write a check and write “Cemetery” in the memo and mail to the First United Methodist Church of Toms River at 129 Chestnut Street Toms River, NJ 08753.

R. Joseph Latshaw, III is a lifelong resident of Toms River, New Jersey, an Eagle Scout, and a graduate of Ocean County College and Kean University, where he earned his bachelor’s degree in history. He works for the Ocean County Cultural & Heritage Commission, contributing to projects commemorating the nation’s semiquincentennial and serving as a docent at Cedar Bridge Tavern County Historic Site. He serves as Church Historian for the First United Methodist Church of Toms River and is active in local historic preservation through the Ocean County Historical Society and the Township of Toms River Historic Preservation Commission.

No Comment
Leave a Comment

Education. Advocacy. Awareness.